| Atlantic Region (First Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Alex Falk | West Liberty |
| Whis Grant | East Stroudsburg |
| Luis Leao | Mercyhurst |
| Chad Moore | Shepherd |
| Isaac Thornton | Fairmont State |
| Byron Westmoreland | Bowie State |
| Coach of Year: Jim Crutchfield (West Liberty) | |
| Atlantic Region (Second Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Darrell Blanton | Gannon |
| Nick Novak | Pittsburgh-Johnstown |
| Trevin Parks | Johnson C. Smith |
| Angelo Sharpless | Elizabeth City State |
| Devin Taylor | Slippery Rock |
| Central Region (First Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Bryton Hobbs | Northeastern State |
| Cameron McCaffrey | Augustana |
| Will McNeill | Washburn |
| Theo Rothstein | St. Cloud State |
| Clayton Vette | Winona State |
| Jarvis Williams | Minnesota State |
| Coach of Year: Matt Margenthaler (Minnesota State) | |
| Central Region (Second Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Dwayne Brunson | Fort Hays State |
| Dominique Long | Central Missouri |
| Zach Roddenberry | Harding |
| Anthony Tucker | Minnesota State-Moorhead |
| Tucker Wentzien | Upper Iowa |
| East Region (First Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Trevon Hamlet | Southern Connecticut State |
| Eric Jean-Guillaume | Franklin Pierce |
| Garret Kerr | University of the Sciences |
| Roy Mabrey | Saint Anselm |
| Dominykas Milka | Saint Rose |
| Akeem Williams | Massachusetts-Lowell |
| Coach of Year: Keith Dickson (Saint Anselm) | |
| East Region (Second Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Tobin Carberry | LIU Post |
| Ellis Cooper | Franklin Pierce |
| Darian David | Bridgeport |
| Justin Exum | New Haven |
| Leon Porter II | Dominican (N.Y.) |
| Midwest Region (First Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Keith DeWitt | Southern Indiana |
| Ali Haidar | Michigan Tech |
| Alex Hall | Drury |
| Greg Kahlig | Findlay |
| Kenny Kornowski | Walsh |
| Jeremy Saffold | Wisconsin-Parkside |
| Coach of Year: Luke Riegel (Wisconsin-Parkside) | |
| Midwest Region (Second Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Chris Dowe | Bellarmine |
| Vance Hall | Bellarmine |
| Ryan Jackson | Lewis |
| Ian Larkin | Wayne State (Mich.) |
| Dazmond Starke | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| South Region (First Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Zane Campbell | Alabama-Huntsville |
| Michael Drake | Christian Brothers |
| Darrien Mack | Eckerd |
| Marcus Ruh | Saint Leo |
| Jaime Smith | Alabama-Huntsville |
| Ellis Young III | West Florida |
| Coach of Year: Lennie Acuff (Alabama-Huntsville) | |
| South Region (Second Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Xavier Collier | Benedict |
| Marcus Goode | Benedict |
| Terry Leake, Jr. | Delta State |
| Julius Reed | Florida Tech |
| Josh Sparks | Valdosta State |
| South Central Region (First Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Craig Foster | Cameron |
| Alex Herrera | Fort Lewis |
| Brandon Jefferson | Metropolitan State |
| Kevin Kotzur | St. Mary's |
| Jonathan Morse | Metropolitan State |
| Corbin Thomas | Midwestern State |
| Coach of Year: Derrick Clark (Metropolitan State) | |
| South Central Region (Second Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Shamar Acuay | Newman |
| Nick Fox | Dallas Baptist |
| Chuck Guy | Tarleton State |
| Kaimyn Pruitt | Adams State |
| Dionelle Rucker | Incarnate Word |
| Southeast Region (First Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Gerald Boston | Barton |
| Tyshawn Good | Belmont Abbey |
| Paul Larsen | South Carolina Aiken |
| Aric Miller | Armstrong Atlantic State |
| Re'mon Nelson | South Carolina Aiken |
| Antonio Stabler | Queens (N.C.) |
| Coach of Year: Vince Alexander (South Carolina Aiken) | |
| Southeast Region (Second Team) | |
| Player | School |
| George Blakeney | North Carolina-Pembroke |
| Charles Blue | Limestone |
| Shahmel Brackett | North Carolina-Pembroke |
| Troran Brown | Montevallo |
| Drico Hightower | Montevallo |
| West Region (First Team) | |
| Player | School |
| Kwame Alexander | Cal State-San Bernardino |
| John Allen | Western Washington |
| Mitchel Anderson | Cal Poly Pomona |
| David Downs | Seattle Pacific |
| Terrence Drisdom | Cal Poly Pomona |
| Paul Jones | Western Washington |
| Coach of Year: Greg Kamansky (Cal Poly Pomona) | |
| West Region (Second Team) | |
| Player | School |
| DeAndre Haskins | Chaminade |
| Joshua Lowery | Grand Canyon |
| Mark McLaughlin | Central Washington |
| Zach Robbins | Dixie State |
| JobI Wall | Seattle Pacific |